Columbus, OH | Hours + Location | Mitchell’s Fish Market (2024)

• MITCHELL’S HOUSE SALAD

  dates, pine nuts, poppy-seed vinaigrette

• CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

  house made dressing, parmesan, croutons

• TITANIC WEDGE OF ICEBERG

  bacon, tomatoes, egg, blue cheese dressing

• NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER

• MAINE LOBSTER BISQUE

• LOBSTER + SHRIMP STUFFED COD

  smashed redskins, asparagus,white wine garlic sauce

• CEDAR ROASTED SALMON

  grilled zucchini + peppers, cedar plank, goat cheese,sundried tomato pesto, balsamic glaze, asparagus

• FILET MIGNON*

  6oz, char-grilled, smashed redskins, asparagus

• SEAFOOD AMERICANA

  sea scallops, cajun shrimp, spinach, mushrooms,shellfish cream sauce over roasted redskins

• ACHIOTE RUBBED SWORDFISH

  shoestring vegetables, crispy yukons,chimichurri butter, chorizo vinaigrette

• DYNAMIC DUO

  lobster + shrimp stuffed lobster tail, bacon wrappedBBQ shrimp, smashed redskins, asparagus

• SHANGHAI SEAFOOD SAMPLER

  steamed scallops, salmon, shrimp,ponzu, ginger, spinach, sticky rice

• SHRIMP + CRAB LINGUINE

  zucchini, mushrooms, peas, basil,tomatoes, white wine garlic sauce

• CRAB CAKE + SHRIMP

  broiled shrimp, maryland style crab cake,corn sauté, classic tartar, smashed redskins

• SEARED SCALLOPS + RISOTTO

  spring pea + shiitake mushroom risotto,lemon beurre blanc, herb oil

• TODAY’S CATCH

  prepared grilled, seared, broiled, or blackened;served with smashed redskins, fresh vegetables

  SALMON

  TUNA

  COD

  SEA BASS

  SWORDFISH

• enhancements

  LOBSTER TAIL $22

  SHRIMP – GRILLED, BLACKENED, or FRIED $7

• VANILLA BEAN CRÈME BRÛLÉE

  caramelized sugar crust, fresh berries

• KEY LIME PIE

  the Fish Market classic, real key lime juice, graham cracker crust

• TURTLE CHEESECAKE

  chocolate, caramel, candied pecans, fresh whipped cream

*Contains or may contain raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Not all ingredients are listed, please advise your server if you have any allergy concerns. For convenience, a Suggested Gratuity of 18% will show on guest checks for banquet events and parties of 8 or more. The amount of gratuity is always discretionary. Feel free to increase or decrease the suggested gratuity amount based on your dining experience.

• New England Seafood Roll

  lobster, shrimp, crab; onion strings, french fries

  $19

• Big Fish Sandwich

  panko encrusted, cheese, lettuce,tomato, onion, tartar, coleslaw, fries

  $16

• Market Double Cheeseburger

  lettuce, tomato, pickle, remoulade, coleslaw, fries

  $17

• Crab Cake Sandwich

  panko crusted, tartar, lettuce, tomato, fries

  $22

• Blackened Fish Tacos

  avocado salsa, pico, lettuce, ranch, queso fresco

  $15

• Lunch Chicken Caesar

  grilled or crispy chicken

  $18.50

• Lunch Fish + Chips

  flash-fried, french fries, hushpuppies, coleslaw

  $19

• Lunch Sixty South® Salmon

  smashed redskins, fresh vegetables

  $21.50

• Lunch Ocean Cobb Salad

  chilled lobster, shrimp + crab “louie”, bacon, egg,avocado, red onion, blue cheese, white balsamic

  $26

• Lunch Maryland Crab Cake

  corn sauté, smashed redskins

  $22

• Lunch Shanghai Sampler

  steamed scallops, salmon, shrimp,ponzu, ginger, spinach, sticky rice

  $26

• Lunch Shrimp Americana

  cajun shrimp, spinach, mushrooms,cream sauce over roasted redskins

  $21.50

Starters

• Half Shell Oysters

  east coast, freshly shucked

  $3.50

• Jumbo Shrimp co*cktail

  5 shrimp, classic co*cktail sauce

  $15.90

• Bacon Wrapped BBQ Shrimp

  applewood bacon, sticky rice

  $14.90

• Crispy Calamari

  chili-soy dipping sauce;green beans, red bell peppers

  $16.50

• Maryland Style Crab Cake

  corn sauté, classic tartar

  $18.50

• Spicy Crispy Shrimp

  creamy chili glaze, sticky rice,pickled cucumbers

  $14.90

• Spinach + Artichoke Dip

  house-made corn chips

  $12.90

• Seared Ahi Tuna

  ale mustard sauce, ponzu, sticky rice,pickled cucumbers, sesame wontons

  $16.50

• Mitchell’s House Salad

  dates, pine nuts, poppy-seed vinaigrette

  $9.50

• The "Chef's Garden" Salad

  mixed greens, green beans, cucumber,fennel, goat cheese, ginger vinaigrette

  $11

• Titanic Wedge of Iceberg

  bacon, tomatoes, egg, blue cheese dressing

  $11

• Classic Caesar

  house made dressing, parmesan, croutons

  $10.50

• New England Clam Chowder

  cup $7.90

  bowl $9.90

• Maine Lobster Bisque

  cup $8.90

  bowl $10.90

• Sixty South® Salmon

  $28.50

• Chilean Sea Bass

  $42

• Atlantic Cod

  $22

• Tilapia

  $19

• Sea Scallops

  $42

• Rainbow Trout

  $30

• Yellowfin Tuna

  $33

• Mahi Mahi

  $28

• Swordfish

  $32

• Alaskan Halibut

  $42

• Ora King Salmon

  $36

• Grilled I Seared I Broiled | Blackened

  smashed redskins, fresh vegetables

• Shanghai Style

  steamed, ponzu, ginger, sticky rice, spinach

Market Signatures

• Lobster + Shrimp Stuffed Cod

  smashed redskins, asparagus,white wine garlic sauce

  $27.50

• Salmon + Purple Peruvian Potatoes

  pumpernickel crumbs, napa cabbage choucroute, whole grain mustard sauce

  $29.50

• Seared Shanghai Sea Bass

  ponzu sauce, spinach, ginger, sticky rice

  $42

• Cedar Roasted Salmon

  grilled zucchini + peppers, cedar plank,sundried tomato pesto, goat cheese,balsamic glaze, asparagus

  $30

• Maryland Style Crab Cakes

  corn sauté, classic tartar, smashed redskins

  $33.90

• Achiote Swordfish

  shoestring vegetables, crispy yukons,chimichurri butter, chorizo vinaigrette

  $34

• Twin Coldwater Lobster Tails

  drawn butter, asparagus, smashed redskins

  $45

• Steamed Crab Legs

  smashed redskins, asparagus, drawn butter;current market pricing:

  King – 1 lb $80

  Snow – 1 lb $32

  1.5 lb $46

  2 lb $59

• Sesame Crusted Tuna

  seared hawaiian ahi, red quinoa + peas, spring pea purée

  $35

• Seafood Americana

  sea scallops, cajun shrimp, spinach,mushrooms, shellfish cream sauceover roasted redskins

  $29.90

• Seared Scallops + Risotto

  spring pea + shiitake mushroom risotto,lemon beurre blanc, herb oil

  $45

• Sam Adams® Hand Battered

  flash-fried, hushpuppies, coleslaw

  fish + chips $23

  shrimp + chips $23.90

Beef + Chicken

• Filet Mignon

  char-grilled, smashed redskins, asparagus

  6 oz $37.50

  8 oz $44.50

• 14oz New York Strip

  smashed redskins, asparagus

  $46

• Chicken Parmesan

  parmesan crusted chicken, marinara,fresh linguine, parmesan cream

  $22

Platters + Combos

• Surf + Turf

  6oz filet mignon, lobster tail,smashed redskins, asparagus

  $59

• Mitchell’s Market Trio

  shrimp, crab cake, broiled salmon,smashed redskins, asparagus

  $37.50

• Crab Cake + Shrimp

  broiled shrimp, maryland style crab cake,corn sauté, classic tartar, smashed redskins

  $29.90

• Steak + Shrimp Americana

  14oz new york strip steak, cajun shrimp, shellfish cream sauce, asparagus, roasted redskins

  $59

• Shanghai Seafood Sampler

  steamed scallops, salmon, shrimp,ponzu, ginger, spinach, sticky rice

  $35

Pastas + Bowls

• Shrimp + Crab Linguine

  zucchini, mushrooms, peas, basil,tomatoes, white wine garlic sauce

  $27

• Ahi Tuna Rice Bowl

  soy-ginger marinade, sticky rice, carrots,pickled cucumbers, scallions, cabbage,avocado-tomatillo, sesame seeds, radishes,sriracha aioli, crispy wontons

  $20.50

• Shrimp Scampi Pasta

  linguine, grape tomatoes, parmesan

  $21

Up In Smoke

• Up In Smoke

  Angel’s Envy Bourbon, Brandy,Campari, Carpano Antica

  $18

Strained Up

• Cucumber Lavender

  Hendrick’s Gin, Prosecco, MoninLavender, fresh lemon, cucumber

  $13

• Pomegranate

  Smirnoff Vodka, PAMA Pomegranate Liqueur,triple sec, pomegranate juice, fresh lime

  $12

• Grapefruit Basil

  Ketel One Vodka,fresh ruby redgrapefruit juice,fresh basil

  $13

• Mitchell's Cosmo

  New Amsterdam Vodka,Cointreau Orange Liqueur,white cranberry juice,fresh lime

  $12

Signatures

• Crushed BlackberryAgave Margarita

  1800 Silver Tequila, Cointreau Orange Liqueur,Monin Agave Nectar, fresh lime, blackberries

  $12

• Moscato White Sangria

  Skyy Blood Orange Vodka, Moscato Wine,fresh lemon, strawberries, oranges

  $11

• Mango-Jito

  Bacardi Superior Rum, Reàl Mango Purée,fresh mint leaves and lime, club soda

  $11

• Millionaire Margarita

  Patrón Silver Tequila,Cointreau OrangeLiqueur, Grand Marnier,fresh lemon sour, lime

  $13

• Yuzu & Dragonfruit

  Calirosa Rosa BlancoTequila, Monin DragonFruit, fresh lime,Fever-Tree Lime & Yuzu

  $14

• Uptown Long Island

  Absolut Citron Vodka,Bacardi Superior Rum,Beefeater Gin,Domaine de CantonGinger Liqueur, freshlemon sour, Sprite

  $13

Trending

• First Impression

  Ketel One Botanical Grapefruit & Rose Vodka,Campari, Ruby Red Grapefruit Juice, fresh lemon

  $13

• Strawberry Mule

  New Amsterdam Vodka, Fever-Tree Ginger Beer,fresh lime, strawberries

  $12

• Brown Derby Old Fashioned

  Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Aperol,Fee Brothers Grapefruit Bitters, honey,club soda

  $14

• Rock & Rye

  Templeton Rye, Grand Marnier, Liber & Co Caramelized Fig Syrup, Fee Brothers Orange Bitters

  $14

• Zest & Bourbon

  Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon,Domaine de Canton Ginger Liqueur,Liber & Co Blood Orange Syrup,fresh lemon, honey,Fee Brothers Orange Bitters

  $14

• Straight Nojito

  Clean Co Rum Alternative,fresh mint, lime, simplesyrup, Owen’s SparklingCucumber Mint

  $13

• Caramel Apple a Day

  Clean Co AppleVodka Alternative,Reàl Apple Purée,Monin Caramel, freshlime, Fre ‘Alcohol-free’Sparkling Brut

  $13

Alcohol-Free

• Grapefruit Cucumber Limeade

  Fresh cucumber, grapefruit, lime, Sprite

  $5

• Sparkling Strawberry Lemonade

  Fresh-squeezed lemonade,Reàl Strawberry Purée, club soda

  $5

• Savannah Peach Tea

  Reàl Peach Purée, fresh-brewed iced tea,lemon sour, mint

  $5

• Raspberry Arnold Palmer

  Reàl Raspberry Purée, fresh lemon juice,fresh-brewed iced tea

  $5

• Mitchell’s Arnold Palmer

  Fresh-brewed iced tea,fresh-squeezed lemonade

  $5

• Fresh-Squeezed Lemonade

  $5

• Refills Only

  $2

Bottle

• Bud Light

• Budweiser

• Coors Light

• Miller Lite

• Corona Extra

• Heineken

• Michelob Ultra

• Angry Orchard Hard Cider Crisp Apple

• New Belgium Fat Tire Ale

• Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

  (Can)

• Modelo Especial

• Stone IPA

• Heineken 0.0

  (non-alcoholic)

Draft

• Blue Moon Belgian White

• Stella Artois

• Sam Adams Boston Lager

• Guinness Stout

Vodka

• Absolut

• Absolut Citron

• Absolut Raspberri

• Absolut Vanilia

• Grey Goose

• Ketel One

• Ketel One Citroen

• Ketel One Grapefruit & Rose

• New Amsterdam

• Skyy Blood Orange

• Smirnoff

• Stolichnaya

• Tito’s Handmade

Rum

• Bacardi Superior

• Captain Morgan Spiced

• Malibu Coconut

• Myers’s Dark

• Pyrat XO Reserve

• Ron Zacapa 23 Yr.

Rye

• Bulleit

• Templeton

Bourbon & Whiskey

• Angel’s Envy

• Bakers

• Booker’s

• Basil Hayden’s

• Bulleit

• Crown Royal

• Elijah Craig Small Batch

• Fireball Cinnamon

• Gentleman Jack

• Jack Daniel’s

• Jameson Irish

• Jim Beam

• Knob Creek

• Maker’s Mark

• Woodford Reserve

• Four Roses Single Barrel

Cognac

• Hennessy V.S.

• Martell Cordon Bleu

• Rémy Martin V.S.O.P.

• Rémy Martin X.O.

• Branson V.S.O.P. Grande Champagne

Scotch

• Balvenie 12 Yr. Doublewood

• Chivas 12 Yr.

• Dewar’s White Label

• Glenfiddich 12 Yr.

• Glenfiddich 15 Yr.

• Glenlivet 12 Yr.

• Glenmorangie 10 Yr.

• Johnnie Walker Black

• Johnnie Walker Red

• Macallan 12 Yr.

• Oban 14 Yr.

Gin

• Aviation

• Beefeater

• Bombay

• Bombay Sapphire

• Hendrick's

• New Amsterdam

• Tanqueray

• Tanqueray No. 10

Mezcal

• Sombra

Tequila

• 1800 Silver

• Avión Silver

• Calirosa Añejo

• Calirosa Rosa Blanco

• Casamigos Añejo

• Casamigos Blanco

• Casamigos Reposado

• Don Julio 1942

• Don Julio Añejo

• Don Julio Reposado

• Patrón Añejo

• Patrón Silver

• Monte Alban

• Teremana Blanco

• 818 Blanco

• 818 Reposado

Ports &Dessert Wine

• Taylor Fladgate 10 Yr.

• Taylor Fladgate 20 Yr.

• Taylor Fladgate LBV

• Fonseca Bin No. 27

• Michele Chiarlo NivoleMoscato d'Asti

Spiked Coffee

• Luxury

  Grand Marnier,Baileys Irish Cream,Frangelico HazelnutLiqueur, whipped cream

  $10

• Keoke

  Kahlúa Coffee Liqueur,Korbel Brandy,whipped cream

  $9

• Irish

  Jameson Irish Whiskey,green crème de menthe,whipped cream

  $9

• Spanish

  Tia Maria Coffee Liqueur,Korbel Brandy

  $9

Happy Hour

• Monday – Sunday3:30 pm – 6:30 pm

$7

• Crispy Crab Rangoons

  spicy mayo, poke sauce

• Spinach & Artichoke Dip

  house-made corn chips

$8

• Shiitake Mushroom Potstickers

  sweet chili ginger butter

• Crispy Calamari

  chili soy dipping sauce, green beans, red bell peppers

• Tomato & Goat Cheese Flatbread

  sundried tomato relish, balsamic, basil

$9

• Crispy Fish Sandwich

  panko crusted, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar

  add french fries $2

• Blackened Fish Street Tacos

  avocado salsa verde, pico de gallo,lettuce, ranchita sauce, queso fresco

• Spicy Crispy Shrimp

  creamy chili glaze, sticky rice, pickled cucumbers

$11

• Double Cheeseburger

  lettuce, tomato, pickle, tartar

  add french fries $2

• Korean BBQ Wings

  spicy mayo & Korean BBQ sauce for dipping

$3.5 Domestic Bottle

• Miller Lite

• Budweiser

• Coors Light

$5 Premium & Import Drafts

• Blue Moon Belgian White

• Columbus Brewing Co IPA

• Great Lakes Seasonal

• Guinness Stout

• Sam Adams Boston Lager

• Stella Artois

$5 Select Spirits

• New Amsterdam Vodka

• New Amsterdam Gin

• Monte Alban Silver Tequila

• Jim Beam Bourbon

• Bacardi Superior Rum

• Dewar's Scotch

$6.5 Premium Spirits

• Tito's Handmade Vodka

• Hendrick's Gin

• Bulleit Bourbon

• 1800 Silver Tequila

• Captain Morgan Spiced Rum

• Johnnie Walker Red Label Scotch

$6 Select Glass Wines

• Lunetta Prosecco

• Fetzer 'Sundial' Chardonnay

• Beringer White Zinfandel

• Ecco Domani Pinot Grigio

• Brancott Sauvignon Blanc

• Chateau Ste Michelle Riesling

• Santa Rita '120 Series' Merlot

• Hayes Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon

$8 Premium Glass Wines

• J. Lohr 'Riverstone' Chardonnay

• Chateau de Berne 'Romance' Rosé

• Villa Rosa Moscato d'Asti

• 14 Hands Cabernet Sauvignon

• Hahn Founder's Pinot Noir

• Trapiche Broquel Malbec

$5 co*cktails

• Moscato White Sangria

  Skyy Blood Orange Vodka, Moscato, simple syrup,fresh lemon juice, strawberries and oranges

• Market Margarita

  Monte Alban 100% Agave Silver Tequila,triple sec, fresh lemon sour and lime juice

• Mango-Jito

  Bacardi Superior Rum, Reàl Mango Purée,fresh mint leaves and lime juice, club soda

$6 Martinis

• Mitchell's Cosmo

  New Amsterdam Vodka, Cointreau Orange Liqueur,white cranberry juice, simple syrup, fresh lime juice

• Pomegranate

  Smirnoff Vodka, PAMA Pomegranate Liqueur,triple sec, pomegranate juice and fresh lime juice

Desserts

• Blueberry Bread Pudding

  maple syrup, whipped cream

  $12

• Sharkfin Pie®

  perfect for sharing, gourmet ice cream, honey roasted peanuts, fudge, peanut butter, oreo cookie crust

  $15

• Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlée

  caramelized sugar crust, fresh berries

  $10.50

• Chocolate Layer Cake

  a chocolate lover's dream, shareable

  $15.50

• New York Style Cheesecake

  seasonal fruit compote

  $11.50

• Key Lime Pie

  the Fish Market classic,real key lime juice, graham cracker crust

  $12

• Signature Carrot Cake

  one of a kind, perfect for sharing

  $17

• Daily Ice Cream + Sorbet

  ask about seasonal and artisanal flavors

  $7

AFTER DINNER ELIXIRS

• Luxury Coffee

  Grand Marnier, Bailey's Irish Cream,Frangelico Hazelnut Liqueur, whipped cream

  $10

• Irish Coffee

  Jameson Irish Whiskey, whipped cream,green crème de menthe

  $9

• Keoke Coffee

  Kahlúa Coffee Liqueur, Korbel Brandy, whipped cream

  $9

• Spanish Coffee

  Tia Maria Coffee Liqueur, Korbel Brandy

  $9

• Impresso Martini

  Stoli Vanil Vodka, Borghetti Espresso Liqueur,Bols Crème de Cacao Liqueur White

  $14

Small Batch Bourbon,Whiskey + Rye

• Angel's Envy

• Baker’s

• Basil Hayden

• Knob Creek

• Booker’s

• Elijah Craig Small Batch

• Bulleit

• Bulleit Rye

• Woodford Reserve

• Templeton Rye

Speyside

• Glenfiddich 12 Yr.

• Glenfiddich 15 Yr.

• Glenlivet 12 Yr.

• Balvenie 12 Yr.

Highlands

• Glenmorangie 10 Yr.

• Macallan 12 Yr.

• Macallan 18 Yr.

• Oban 14 Yr.

Cognac

• Hennessy V.S.

• Martell Cordon Bleu

• Rémy Martin V.S.O.P.

• Rémy Martin X.O.

• Branson V.S.O.P Grande Champagne

Rum

• Ron Zacapa 23 Yr.

• Don Pancho 8 Yr.

• Pyrat X.O. Reserve

Port + Dessert Wine

• Taylor Fladgate 10 Yr.

• Taylor Fladgate 20 Yr.

• Taylor Fladgate Lbv

• Fonseca Bin No. 27

• Michele Chiarlo Nivole Moscato D'Asti

Tequila

• Avión Silver

• Don Julio Añejo

• Don Julio Blanco

• Don Julio Reposado

• Don Julio 1942

• 818 Blanco

• 818 Reposado

• Calirosa Rosa Blanco

• Calirosa Añejo

• Casamigos Reposado

• Casamigos Añejo

• Casamigos Blanco

• Patrón Silver

• Patrón Añejo

• Komos Cristalino Añejo

Cold Platters

• Jumbo co*cktail Shrimp

  12 piece minimum

  $3 per piece

  inquire for additional sizes

• Caprese Skewers

  12 piece minimum

  $3.30 per skewer

• Vegetable Crudites

  serves 8 - 12 guests $40

• Cheese + Fruit

  serves 8 - 12 guests $69

Hot Platters

• Chicken Satay Skewers

  12 piece minimum

  $2.50 per skewer

• Spinach & Artichoke Dip

  serves 8 - 12 guests $49

• Bacon Wrapped Shrimp

  12 piece minimum

  $2.50 per piece

• Flameless Chafing Kits are required for all hot selections.

• $17.00

• Grilled Chicken Sandwich

  with french fries

• Fish Tacos

  with french fries

• Cheese Burger

  with french fries

• Chicken Caesar Salad

  with garlic cheese bread

• delivery available in certain markets

• $37

  Salad or Soup

  Two Entrées

  Two Sides

• $39

  Salad or Soup

  Two Entrées

  Three Sides

• $50

  Salad and Soup

  Three Entrées

  Three Sides

• Salad Choice of Caesar or House

  Soup Choice of Clam Chowder or Lobster Bisque

• Entrées

  (served family style)

  Cedar Roasted Salmon

  Chicken Parmesan

  Shrimp Scampi Pasta

  Pecan Crusted Trout

  Seafood Americana

  Eggplant Milanese (vegetarian)

  Add Filet Mignon 6oz | $32 per guest

• Sides

  Roasted Redskin Potatoes

  Sticky Rice

  Sweet Corn Sauté

  Mashed Potatoes

  Sautéed Green Beans

  Market Vegetables

• Upgrades

  Flameless Hot or Cold Chafing Kits | each $15

  each additional hour of heat $7.50

• Shrimp Boil

  lb $29

• King Crab Boil

  lb $75

• Combination

  lb $55

• Add a Lobster Tail

  $22

Whole Desserts

• New York Cheesecake

  $69

• Key Lime Pie

  $75

• Chocolate Layer Cake

  $95

• Carrot Cake

  $95

Beverages

• Mocktails

  $26 per 1/2 gallon

  Berry Faux-Jito

  Sparkling Cucumber

  Strawberry Basil Lemonade

  Black Cherry Palmer

  Peach Palmer

• Iced Tea

  $12 per gallon

• Bottled Water

  $4.40